Saturday, November 17, 2012

探求“針尖芥子“之義


為了瞭解“針尖芥子“之意,用 Google 搜尋了一下,在大乘經典裡,大致是說很難得的意思,如:

  1. 佛經上說「正法極難值遇」,《涅槃經》上比喻為「從兜率天投一芥子至閻浮提的針尖上」;
  2. 把芥子往朝上的針尖上撒,芥子極難立在針尖上,得暇满人身寶就像這樣難;


但是針尖芥子的形容最早應該出現在南傳《法句經》:

401. Like water on a lotus leaf, or a mustard seed on the point of a needle, he who does not cling to sensual pleasures — him do I call a holy man.

針尖上的芥子有如蓮葉上的水,都不會附著。這偈經文的意思是:

猶如水落於蓮葉,亦如置芥子於針尖;
不染著於愛欲者,可以稱他為婆羅門。

所以古漢譯《法句經》就直接譯為:

心棄惡法,如蛇脫皮;不為欲污,是謂梵志。

但是我一開始並未理解到這個意思,直到我查詢到《清淨道論》說到:

當他嘗試分別諸界時,其瞋恨即找不到立足處,就好像在針尖的芥子,或像在空中油漆。

在空中油漆自然油不上去。要想置芥子於針尖,雖然不是不可能,但很容易就掉下來。

《清淨道論》也是南傳重要的論典,地位相當於北傳的《瑜伽師地論》。
這樣一來,雖然我們知道針尖上的芥子和蓮葉上的水滴或在空中油漆一樣,不容易附著,但針尖芥子的意思卻因上下文而有不同的意涵。前者強調不繫著,後者是說找不到立足處,已經很接近大乘經典的說法 -- 同樣是說不容易,大乘經典是在強調稀有及殊勝,《清淨道論》則用來形容事情很難成辦。


但是我之所以對針尖芥子的狀態形象發生興趣是因為佛陀大弟子舍利弗的一首詩,《Upon the Tip of a Needle》,其中的一段是這樣寫的:

With no production there's no birth;
With becoming present, one lives.
When grasped with the highest meaning,
The world is dead when the mind stops.
若不起念頭就不會發生,因為有了念頭所以存在;
一旦念頭消失,東西也會跟著不見。
當你思考人生的意義時:
世界會隨著你的意念停止而滅亡!

There's no hoarding what has vanished,
No piling up for the future;
Those who have been born are standing
Like a seed upon a needle.
過去已經消失的無法保存,在未來也不會有積累,
現在還在的則如針尖上的芥子。

這裡的針尖芥子正是形容我們人身,亦即你我及每個人,目前存在的狀態及本質!

(寫到這裡,日本剛發生的地震海嘯正好印證了這個說法。)


這樣針尖芥子就有了第三個意涵,說明了存續狀態的脆弱。

舍利弗是佛陀的大弟子,智慧第一,也是《心經》中觀自在菩薩口中的舍利子。
他之所以會寫下這首詩是為了解釋《經集.義品》中窟八偈經(The Cave of the Body)裡的第四偈:

So a person should train right here & now.
Whatever you know as out-of-tune in the world,
don't, for its sake, act out-of-tune,
for that life, the enlightened say, is short.
人生當覺是:
若是知道有什麼不當作的就別去作,因為人生太短,沒有時間讓人後悔。


詩中的針尖芥子正是對人生太短有感而發,但是不僅於此,它還說明了是怎樣的短,如何的短。人的經驗是一連串的感知過程,藉著仔細的觀察省思,可以發現這些心理作用的昇起和離去。我們以為這些感知是"我們的"感知;事實上,構成這些一瞬即逝的感知經驗的元素大家都一樣;譬如,每一個人都有苦樂的感受。

每一刻的心理狀態當然是獨特的,但那部份是因為心緒組成的當下的資料(氛圍情調)不同,部份因為受體(個性)的組成不同;這一切就跟電腦會因為電腦本身結構及所處理的資料的變化所產生的結果一樣。電腦不會以為這些結果是“我的“。

我們主觀的世界就是這樣創造出來的,在我們沉沉入睡或死去時,世界也就一起消滅。芥子立於針尖的形象是如此精確的描述了人的情況 -- 過去的已經過去,未來仍一片混沌。我們能夠掌握者僅有當下,而且只有在我們清醒的時候,只要我們昏昏欲睡,芥子馬上會從針尖上掉落。


*窟八偈經(The Cave of the Body)將人的身體比喻成一個洞窟,人因為受制於身體的感知欲望所以無明,就如將自己關在一個洞窟之中;而修行之所以難,正是因為一切都要靠自己,沒有人可以將你從洞窟解救出來。

**《Upon the Tip of a Needle》於《清淨道論》<第二十說道非道智見清淨品>中,亦被引用來幫助修習毗鉢舍那提起無常、苦及無我等三相。

Thursday, July 14, 2011

序論六

諸比丘,有情的清净......
作証涅槃的一乘之道,即四念住。 《雜阿含》六O 七经(大正二·一七一a)

有一乘道,淨諸眾生,令越憂悲,滅惱苦,得如實法,所謂四念處。
何等為四?身身觀念處,受、心、法法觀念處。


Bhikkhus, this path is the only way for the purification of beings,... for the
realization of nibbana, that is to say, the four Foundations of Mindfulness.


Bhikkhus, this is the one-way path for the purification of beings,
for the overcoming of sorrow and lamentation,
for the passing away of pain and displeasure,
for the achievement of the method,
for the realization of Nibbåna, that is,
the four foundations of mindfulness. SN 47.1

引經要旨:說明清净道在某些地方则是「四念處」的意思。


有意贊助者,請來信或留言。

序論五

一切戒圆具,有慧善等持,
精進勤勇者,渡難渡暴流。 《雜阿含》一三一六经(大正二·三六一c)。

誰度於諸流  晝夜勤不懈
不攀無住處  云何不沒溺
一切戒具足  智慧善正受
內思惟正念  能度難度流
不染此欲想  超度彼色愛
貪喜悉已盡  不入於難測


He who is possessed of constant virtue,
Has understanding, and is concentrated,
Is strenuous and diligent as well,
Will cross the flood so difficult to cross.


Who here crosses over the flood,
Unwearying by day and night?
Who does not sink in the deep,
Without support, without a hold?

One always perfect in virtue,
Endowed with wisdom, well concentrated,
One energetic and resolute
Crosses the flood so hard to cross.
One who desists from sensual perception,
Who has overcome the fetter of form,
Who has destroyed delight in becoming—
He does not sink in the deep.
SN 2.15

引經要旨:說明清净道在某些地方则是「正戒」、「戒等」的意思。


有意贊助者,請來信或留言。

序論四

業與明及正法,戒與最上活命,
人依此等清净,不由姓與财净。 《雜阿含》五九三经(大正二·一五八c)。

於此祇桓林  仙人僧住止
諸王亦住此  增我歡喜心
深信淨戒業  智慧為勝壽
以此淨眾生  非族姓財物
大智舍利弗  正念常寂默
閑居修遠離  初建業良友


By deeds, vision and righteousness,
By virtue, the sublimest life--
By these are mortals purified,
And not by lineage and wealth.


This indeed is that Jeta’s Grove,
The resort of the Order of seers,
Dwelt in by the Dhamma King,
A place that gives me joy.
Action, knowledge, righteousness,
Virtue, an excellent life:
By this are mortals purified,
Not by clan or wealth.
Therefore a person who is wise,
Out of regard for his own good,
Should carefully examine the Dhamma:
Thus he is purified in it.
Såriputta truly is endowed with wisdom,
With virtue and with inner peace.
Even a bhikkhu who has gone beyond
At best can only equal him. SN 2.20


引經要旨:說明清净道在某些地方则是「正業」、「業等」、「正確的作為」的意思。

In some instances this path of purification is taught by deeds(kamma).


有意贊助者,請來信或留言。

Saturday, July 9, 2011

序論三

禅慧兼有者,彼实近涅槃。  《法句經》沙门品(大正四·五七二a)。

無禪不智   無智不禪  
道從禪智   得至泥洹

He is near unto nibbana
In whom are jhana and understanding.

There is no meditative concentration for him who lacks insight, and no insight for him who lacks meditative concentration. He in whom are found both meditative concentration and insight, indeed, is close to Nibbana. Dhp. 372

﹡這裡又把慧譯成 insight; 慧學在南傳佛教來說,似乎就相當於毗鉢舍那。

引經要旨:說明清净道在某些地方则作定與慧的意思。


有意贊助者,請來信或留言。

序論二

一切行無常,當以慧見時,
得厭離于苦,此乃清净道。《法句经》道行品(大正四·五六九b)

知眾行空   是為慧見  
罷厭世苦   從是道除

(吳譯法句經以空代替無常)

Formations are all impermanent:
When he sees thus with understanding
And turns away from what is ill,
That is the path to purity.

"All conditioned things are impermanent" — when one sees this with wisdom, one turns away from suffering. This is the path to purification.       Dhp. 277

引經要旨:說明清净道在某些地方只是毗鉢舍那之意。"清淨"應理解為涅槃,即是已無任何染污;故清淨道是通往涅槃之道,此為一般的解釋;然而,某些經文中則僅指毗鉢舍那,如本經之例。


有意贊助者,請來信或留言。

Friday, July 8, 2011

序論一


内结與外结,人為结缚结,
瞿曇我问汝,誰當解此结?

住戒有慧人,修習心與慧,
有勤智比丘,彼當解此结。 


外纏結非纏  內纏纏眾生
今問於瞿曇  誰於纏離纏    

智者建立戒  內心修智慧
比丘勤修習  於纏能解纏      《雜阿含》五九九经

漢譯並未將戒、定、慧三學之意旨譯出;別譯雜阿含173經則有:

堅持立禁戒,修心及智慧,
懃行於精進,具念名比丘,
速能令結髮,作於不結髮。


The inner tangle and the outer tangle--
This generation is entangled in a tangle,
And so I ask of Gotama this question:
Who succeeds in disentangling this tangle?

When a wise man, established well in Virtue(戒),
Develops Consciousness(定) and Understanding(慧),
Then as a bhikkhu ardent and sagacious
He succeeds in disentangling this tangle.


A tangle inside, a tangle outside,
This generation is entangled in a tangle.
I ask you this, O Gotama,
Who can disentangle this tangle?

A man established on virtue, wise,
Developing the mind and wisdom,
A bhikkhu ardent and discerning:
He can disentangle this tangle.        SN 1.23

引經要旨:開宗明義,本論即在闡釋戒定慧三學的清淨道。




有意贊助者,請來信或留言。